Reservation
+1 706-972-7791
Visit Us
2400 GA-52, Ellijay, GA 30536, United States
Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Chicken Marinara
Garden Salad
Meatball Sub
Chicken Sub
About
Cartecay River Pizza Company
Welcome to Cartecay River Pizza Company, a hidden gem nestled in the picturesque town of Ellijay, Georgia. Located at 2400 GA-52, this charming eatery is not just about wood-fired pizza; it’s an experience that brings together quality food and a warm, inviting atmosphere. As you step inside, you're greeted by retro decor that instantly sets a laid-back vibe, making it the perfect spot for a casual meal with friends or family.
What elevates your visit to Cartecay River Pizza Company are the friendly faces that greet you. Customers have raved about the exemplary customer service provided by staff members like Tiffany, who is known for her helpful nature and welcoming demeanor. A pleasant ambiance combined with hospitable service sets the stage for an enjoyable dining experience.
The culinary crown jewel here is undoubtedly the wood-fired pizza, known for its aromatic, flavorful crust that strikes a perfect balance between crispy and chewy. Many patrons recommend trying the Margherita pizza, likening its crust to a finely crafted work of art, although opinions vary on the sweetness of the sauce. The thrill of testing the inner tip's structural integrity—what we call the gravity test—adds a playful element to your dining adventure.
Beyond pizza, the menu does not disappoint. With delightful options like meatball sliders and wings, Cartecay offers a robust selection for any foodie. However, reviews suggest a slight inconsistency with the wings, which some have found lacking in texture. A simple suggestion to refine their cooking technique could elevate them to match the high standards set by the pizza.
As I savor each bite of their garlic-laden wood-fired creations, I can't help but feel a connection to the local community that this establishment fosters. The fresh toppings and quick service make it hard not to appreciate the love and effort put into every dish. It’s the kind of place that invites you back again and again, not just for the food, but for the feeling of familiarity and warmth.
In summary, Cartecay River Pizza Company is a must-visit for lovers of great pizza and exceptional customer service. Whether you're dining in or taking out, this eatery promises an experience that will keep you coming back for more. Don’t miss out on this delightful hole-in-the-wall that has quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ I believe the owner is super smart...first time here...when I walked in the door, a client said the pizza was great..then the decor was retro cool...the pizza was really top shelf...but the best thing was Tiffany....super helpful and a really nice person... I'll be back for sure ”
“ We were warmly greeted on our 1st visit. Super sweet employees who are exemplary in customer service- A The was pretty dang good. That being said, pizza is very subjective. We tried the Margherita... crust was flavorful, nice chew and the inner tip held up well to the gravity test . Just an opinion- the sauce was a touch too sweet and lacked well roundness in flavor. The sliced tomatoes were just okay. I'd give it a fair 7.75/10 for GA pizza. • Meatball sliders were good. • Wings. These fell short, a disappointment for having the oven that ya'll do. The fat wasn't rendered, and the skin was rubbery. We had to take them home & pop in the air fryer to enjoy them. Suggestion is to par cook them, and finish in your oven. If in the area and craving pizza, we'd likely stop in again ...customer service is to thank ”
“ Great wood fired pizza, we also had wings and they were excellent as well. It’s a must visit place, limited seating. We got takeout. ”
“ Delicious!! Wood fire pizza, and it was fast! So good, nice and garlicky! Ceasar salad was fresh too! If you're looking for a great hole in the wall place with delicious pizza you found it! We will be back! ”
“ We've had takeout in the past but It's been a while... So, we decided to stop in again and check it out. The Pizza and service couldn't have been any better. Great thin and crispy crust... perfect... and the topping were super fresh. We'll definitely be stopping in more often!! ”
“ I love it!!!! Super nice place with a nice atmosphere, and the pizzas amazing!!!!!! O...M...G!!! What a tasty pizza. I recommend 100% to everyone, so stop by and enjoy like we did. 5 stars. Good job. ”
“ Easily top 3 pizza places in Ellijay, far superior to any chain. A little pricey, but worth it. Friendly staff, great ingredients, and wood fired pizza make this place shine. We’re locals, so they’ll def be in our rotation in the future. ”
“ We did a Google search for some pizza and this place come up. We were hesitant at first because of the river rafting rental signs. The reviews told us to look past it and try it. We were greeted by a hostess that handed us a menu. Our eyes went to the River Rat pizza. Great name for the theme in the establishment. It has bacon, tomatoes, garlic, and basil, This pie was heated to perfection in a wood stove oven. Patience is a virtue. Especially for fresh ingredients and a hand-tossed pie. The outer crust has that crunchiness you expect and dark spots from the oven. The bottom of the slice has some corn meal to keep it from getting burnt and from my experience of eating makes for a better slice. The dough inside was soft, a good compliment to the sweet marinara sauce. The tomatoes are sweet and cut medium, which paired well with the basil, garlic, and bacon. Aldo asked us how we liked the pie. In talking to him we find out he is the new owner and has been opened a week. He has a lot of plans to expand the restaurant. The oven can only bake two pies but more when the expansion is completed. The menu has also been improved with fresher ingredients. If you were disappointed with the previous owner please give Aldo and his menu a try. I think you'll like it!! ”